Seafood, Sandwiches and More

Seafood, Sandwiches and More

Visit our family-friendly restaurant located in Barnegat and serving Toms River, Manahawkin, Waretown, LBI, Bayville and Ocean County, NJ


Our formal dining room offers something for everyone, with a menu featuring eclectic American dishes like:

  • Seafood
  • Salads
  • Sandwiches
  • Build-Your-Own Custom Burgers
  • Steaks
  • Chops
  • Chicken

We also serve a variety of home-style favorites. Visit Lefty's Tavern today to be treated like family.

Curbside Takeout is available

Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or want to sit down for a romantic dinner, Lefty's Tavern is the place to be. Sit back and toast the end of a long work week with a glass of wine or a frosty pint of beer, or stop in when you feel like those weekday blues can't be cooked away at home.

Our restaurant is also a great place for families, early-diners and night owls alike. Enjoy our full menu, which you can order from all day long. Make a Reservation on Yelp (click the button below) to be sure or Walk-ins are always welcome. Come to Lefty's Tavern and enjoy your favorite meal any time of day in Barnegat, NJ or have food catered to the surrounding areas including Toms River, Manahawkin, Waretown, LBI, Bayville and Ocean County, NJ.

The Garden Room At Lefty's Tavern

Outdoor Dining Coming Soon (Weather Permitting)